Thursday, December 4, 2014

The Giver: The Selection (chapter 5-8)

     In this last week I had read the chapters five through eight, and all of them gives us a better insight of the community, its rules, inhabitants and Jonas. When Jonas have his first Stirring, he is given a pill to negate it from happening again, even if he enjoyed it was a rule to take them. Then when the ceremonies began at the Auditorium, they started giving the first day the newchildren that became Ones, Gabe has a second year for nurturing, and the Eights had new jackets and started volunteer hours. In the second day of the ceremonies they began by giving the Nines their bicycles, and so on with the Ten and Eleven. When the Ceremony of the Twelve began, they started giving the Assignments to the new Twelves, such as Asher being Assistant Recreation Director or Fiona being a Caretaker of the Old, but they skipped Jonas. However after the Ceremony the Chief Elder said that Jonas have been chosen as the new Receiver of memories and he would be taken as apprentice by the old one, all the community chanted Jonas name giving him a new, a different life as the new Receiver of memories.




     I had been asking myself, what does this quotes means "He saw the others in his group glance at him, embarrassed, and then avert their eyes quickly. He saw a worried look on the face of his group leader." Does it means that they thought that Jonas was in trouble, or would be released in public? Did they thought that he had been taken over for being a disgrace for the group and community? Or did they thought that he would be punished for something he had made to the Chief Elder or to anyone of the community? Finally, did they thought that maybe Jonas was going to be given a serious chastisement that would change him forever?


     After reading this four chapters I had started to think, is that the Receiver is praised by people but at the same time people fear his job and look reluctantly to be with him. Even the Elders are reluctant to be around him because he had experiences that no one comprehend, and no one comprehend him. People also see in awe to the Receiver as he always have the answer to everything, and is just with everyone. However his apprentice, meaning Jonas, is seen with the respect the Chief Elder is given and at the same time people start to become scared of him as they think that he is already different from the community, in general. Finally, the Receiver accepts this from an early age, and with time he or she starts to accept that they are not a hundred percent a part of the community any more. 


8 comments:

  1. Hi Joaquin !
    I had a hard time reading your blog because it made me question so much things that you pointed out. I like all the inferences that you made, because they make peoploe think and might changes perspectives of the book. In my case it really did, know I realize new things about the text. Great blog !

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Camila!
      I appreciate your comment. However I would like to know what you questioned about. And things in this text were merely cosise, so it was nothing to good in my opinion. However I appreciate you reading it carefully and I liked you liked my inferences. Give me your blog URL so I can see yours too.

      Delete
  2. Joaquin I think that you're blog show a good understanding on what is happening and is really good that you diffine sow well you're points and I agree with you in the point of the receiver and I found it pretty interesting.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nico:
      Thanks for your comment and I like to see that you agree with me, the same as Camila. However I would like to know a litle better what you really think about my post, for me your comment makes me ask what specific part of the Reciver comment you liked. Finally I would like to know what you think that are the reasons that the Reciver is so secluded from the other Elders
      Thank you for your comment Nico!

      Delete
  3. Joaquin, I can agree with you when you say that The Receiver is a person that the community fear because in the book it says that everyone was surprised when they announced that he had been selected instead of assigned. Also, I think that having that job makes you be the most respected person of the community.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Andrea!
      I too like the part of the community fearing and respecting the Reciver. However I would like to know your opinion of the community and your perspective of how is the Reciver seen. Even if you agree with me you should have another insight too.
      Thanks a lot for your comment, and comment again: Joaquin Yepez

      Delete
  4. Joaquin, why do you believe people are resultant to be round the Receiver of Memories? Also the book said that the receiver of memories is the most important job in the community. If that is so the Receiver of memories should be part of the community, being the glue that somehow holed it together. What do you think?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rafaela, I see the people relucant to be around the Reciver of Memories as he is the only one that had felt the true taste of life. He can take all their secrests, and people can never know when he is saying the truth. Even if it is the most important job, it is also the less loved one and no one want to have it. He don`t hold the community together, for he or she is an outsider and people try to avoid it, as the Elders are never sitted alongside him. However your comment made me think and I thank you for that.
      Keep commenting, I appreciate it.

      Delete